Growing up I remember the gossip within the Korean church community about people that would go to mental health therapy. It seemed to be strictly reserved for those that are “severely depressed” or “crazy”. Being Asian-American myself, my goal is to provide context around the cultural, spiritual, and generational differences found within my culture. It is in this effort to break down sensitivities and encourage the sharing of stories that I hope to help create a sense of shared-experience or understanding for anyone feeling isolated within their mental health.
Before Jumping In
First thing first! We are going to recognize several barriers and negative stigmas surrounding mental health so that we can look at what is needed for this next generation of Asian-Americans to consider pursuing the care that they need. I would like to note that these are not exclusive to only Asian-American communities, and can influence other racial or ethnic groups within minorities.
Cultural Differences & Shared Shame
“Why do I need to go talk to a random stranger?” “Shouldn’t my elders and parents know what’s best for me?” Although Asian-American culture has influence from Individualistic cultures like the U.S., there is still a prevailing sense of community interdependence. There is hesitancy before an approach to outside people for help with personal matters. Actively seeking professional help can be a form of admittance that something is wrong with me and my family. Asian-American culture is rooted in shame-based culture as well. What I mean is that problems are usually contained in the confines of the family unit. If, for example, people found out that someone they know is going through mental health therapy, their whole family is shamed along with that individual.
“If you admit you need help for your mental health, parents and other family members might experience fear and shame. They may assume that your condition is a result of their poor parenting or a hereditary flaw, and that you’re broken because of them.” – Ryann Tanap from National Alliance of Mental Illness
Spiritual Beliefs: “We’re Fine.”
According to a nationwide survey in 2012 by the Pew Research Center, Christians are the largest religious group among U.S. Asian adults at 42%, and 31% have another religious affiliation (Buddhist, Hindu, Muslim, etc). Not all religious communities frown upon mental health therapy, but this spiritual dynamic can either be a gateway or barrier to seeking much-needed aid. Since we are addressing barriers, here is what that would look like. Even the mention of seeking professional help in a church could be taken as a sign of weakness because it may be assumed you are not dependant enough on your faith. People experiencing mental health symptoms could be afraid of telling others in fear of judgment, so
The Generational Gap
Many Asian-American millennials were raised under immigrant parents that did not have a framework for discussing mental health the way we do today. So, it comes upon outside sources to teach the Asian-American community about mental health conditions and that it may take more than merely toughing it out. Millennials may feel that their immigrant parents went through more difficulties to make it in the U.S., so they see their mental health struggles as minuscule to what their parents faced. It is a classic example of comparison which diminishes one’s present reality.
Mental Health Understanding
Lastly, the terms Major Depressive Disorder, Generalized Anxiety Disorder, Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder, and many others in the DSM-V used for diagnosis are developed from a Western medicine perspective. Within Asian cultures, the conceptualization of mental illnesses
While there are many negative stigmas to debunk between clinical and layman language, we are seeing the beginning of the much-needed education to address these questions, which needs to be continually made more readily available to this community.
Continuing to Learn & Share
Thankfully, there have been more efforts on many different levels of society to increase awareness of mental health among the Asian-American community and reduce the stigma of seeking out professional help. These are all important steps to reducing the taboo sense surrounding mental health, and
If you are carrying your problems alone or struggling with the privacy and shame that’s commonplace as an Asian-American, please give me a call. I’d happily walk alongside anyone who is hesitant or even doesn’t know who to reach out to or how. Please consider booking an appointment with me when you’re ready.
Written by therapist Daniel Pak
More Optimum Joy Articles
Right now, everyone is making many sacrifices because of the extended impact of stay-at-home orders, cancelled events, cancelled vacations, job loss, and so many other disappointing things. Many people are missing out on weddings, graduations, proms, birthdays and...
Our founder Alexandra Hoerr joins a pastor, psychiatrist, and an individual who has experienced the benefits of counseling to discuss the complexities of integrating spiritual wellbeing and Christian living with counseling. While the church has historically been...
Pamela Larkin, a mental health therapist at Optimum Joy Clinical Counseling, joins Alexandra Hoerr to discuss navigating the racial tension which plagues our nation. Pam brings a wealth of experience, including her professional and personal experience of being a...